Defense claims murder-suicide in Entwistle's trial
WOBURN, Mass. -- A British man accused of killing his wife and 9-month-old daughter put up no witnesses in his defense before resting the case Monday, but his attorneys came up with an alternative theory for jurors to consider: that the woman had fatally shot the baby and committed suicide.
A jury was set to begin deliberating the fate of Neil Entwistle, who is accused of fatally shooting 27-year-old Rachel and their daughter, Lillian, in their Hopkinton home in 2006.
Jurors were set to begin deliberations on Tuesday.
In closing arguments Monday, Entwistle's lawyer, Elliot Weinstein, told the jury that Rachel Entwistle shot the baby and then killed herself. Her 29-year-old husband covered up her actions to "protect her honor," he argued before resting the case.
Assistant District Attorney Michael Fabbri, however, dismissed that theory, noting the couple had recently returned to the United States so Rachel could be near her family in Massachusetts. The couple had lived in England for several years before that.
"Why would Rachel commit suicide?" Fabbri asked. "She was back home, she had her home, she had her car, she had her family, and she thought she had a loving husband."
Prosecutors have argued that Entwistle killed his family because he was dissatisfied with his sex life, despondent about not being able to find a job and wanted to start a new life.
The couple had just moved into their rented home 10 days earlier, and by all accounts, appeared to be happy and madly in love with their daughter, according to numerous witnesses who testified during the three-week trial.
Fabbri urged jurors to consider evidence that pointed to "the two sides of Neil Entwistle," including his visits to Internet sex sites in the days and weeks before the slayings.
Weinstein, however, argued that police failed to consider suicide because they immediately focused on Entwistle as a suspect when he flew home to England the day after the killings.
Entwistle told police he returned home from running errands on Jan. 20, 2006, and found his wife and daughter cuddled together in bed, dead from apparent gunshot wounds.
"Neil found Rachel and Lillian dead. Neil saw that (.22-caliber gun) and knew instantly what happened, and in those moments, he knew what he had to do," Weinstein said.
The defense lawyer said Entwistle returned the gun to the home of his father-in-law, Joseph Matterazzo, so that his wife's family would not know she had committed suicide. Police later determined that Matterazzo's .22-caliber handgun was used in the killings.
"Everything that Neil did after finding Rachel and Lillian in that bedroom, he did because he loved them," Weinstein said.
Fabbri, however, cast doubts on the credibility of that argument, citing the reconstruction of the crime scene.
Holding the long-barreled gun in court, the prosecutor said that in order for that argument to make sense, the jury would have to believe that Rachel Entwistle shot her baby through the chest, had that bullet lodge in her own breast, then raise the gun over her head and shoot herself at the top of her head, just beyond her hairline.
"It could not have happened the way they said it did," Fabbri said.
Fabbri sought to highlight a circumstantial evidence to convince jurors that that the man killed his wife and baby daughter. He pressed the jury to consider a string of failures Entwistle had had in the months before the killings.
Since moving to Massachusetts four months earlier, Entwistle had been unable to find a job, had had several Internet-based businesses fail and had been looking for sex online through Web sites for escort services and a swingers' site called AdultFriendFinder.com.
"He was failing to provide for his family, and whether that justified homicide, I am not going to stand here and tell you that makes any sense," Fabbri said.
Weinstein had Entwistle had no motive to kill his wife and daughter, and said the Web sites he visited are used by millions of people every day.
"There is no motive, no motive to kill the woman, who by everyone's account, he shared a joyful, loving and caring relationship," Weinstein said.
(Copyright (c) 2008 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.)